JAR Home
Jellyfish Anime Reviews
 
 
Fullmetal Alchemist
Genre(s):  Action, Comedy, Drama
Released:  2003
Episodes:  51 TV

The Law of Equivalent Trade, a law stating that nothing can be gained without a sacrifice, governs a world where alchemy takes the place of science. Two young brothers, Edward and Alphonse Elric, are living a happy childhood with their caring mother. In their spare time, they begin to study alchemy together, but their lives are changed when their mother dies. The two brothers decide that they want to revive their mother by attempting the great alchemical taboo: Human Transmutation.


Homunculus Gluttony
5/5
Fullmetal Alchemist is one of those series that only comes around once in a while. I can’t predict yet just how influential will be in the future, but I suspect that this is the next Escaflowne or Bebop. With the recent license and its air on Cartoon Network, it’s sure to be the next big thing on these shores as well. As soon as you know that this is a Bones series, however, it shouldn’t come off as a surprise.

The story is one of the most original that I have seen in quite a while. Not only does the way things progress throughout the series keep you interested from the first scene to the last scene, but the basic premise itself is a departure from the average shounen series (which this quite obviously is, although it’s leagues above most such series). I am yet to see a series other than this one that has such a large focus on alchemy, or one that uses the Seven Deadly Sins as the main villains. The plot keeps you guessing through and through and is filled with plot twists that you never see coming. The ending has perfect closure and surprisingly effective usage of an epilogue, although there are many things unanswered – there is a movie coming in 2005, however, that will be a direct sequel to the series, so there is still hope for a true ending.

The world of Fullmetal Alchemist is beautiful. The backgrounds are impressive, but the best parts about the world of this series are the rich cultures that develop in each country. From the calm lifestyle led by the residents of the Elric brothers’ home village to the religious-based culture of the desert countries in Ishbal, the people always have their own reasons for living and for the ways they act. Thanks to this, it is not difficult to sympathize with the many different conflicting cultures, and often you find yourself wondering about who is actually in the right.

In the midst of this rich and beautiful world you have a cast of characters so realistic and well-developed that you find yourself wanting to watch the next episode if only to see more of the interactions between them. The two brothers stand at the head of the large cast, and are beyond doubts the two most spectacular protagonists in any shounen series yet. The Seven Deadly Sins are fascinating villains, although the focus of the story does not fall on them until the halfway point. Backing up the brothers and the Sins you have the conflict between the religious Ishbalites and the government-military, which also does not lack in impressive characters with vivid personalities.

The physical aspect of the series, that is, animation and music, sometimes leaves more to be desired. The music matches every scene well, but tends to pale in comparison to what’s happening on the screen at the moment. Given, it’s good listening, but if you haven’t watched the series, you probably wouldn’t think much of the soundtrack. The background music is nothing compared to scores by, say, Kajiura Yuki or Yoko Kanno, and it’s a shame, because Fullmetal Alchemist is a series that could be more effective with a superb score, more so than it already is. The openings and endings, however, are excellent. From openings by Porno Graffitti, L’arc~en~Ciel, Asian Kung-Fu Generation and the promising new Cool Joke, to one of the greatest endings of any series I’ve ever seen, by Nana Kitade, the series is chock-full of great ways of introducing and concluding each episode. The animation starts out strong throughout the first quarter of the series, but from that point on, when compared to the early animation, some scenes leave more to be desired. The important things, however, are beautifully animated in the style I have come to expect from Bones.

When it comes down to a final verdict, I cannot recommend Fullmetal Alchemist more. Watching it week by week as each episode came out in Japan was especially a treat, because now I can honestly say that the plot kept me entertained for an entire year. Although I can’t guarantee that all anime fans will love it, most should, especially if you are looking for a good, refreshing adventure story filled with realistic and memorable characters.

Likes - Superb story, great characters, well-developed world, and excellent openings and ending sequences
Dislikes - The background music is too bland and the animation is not always up to par; some aspects of the ending are extremely frustrating in their ambiguity

Average User Rating: 3.38/5 (34 votes)
 

Comment on Review
Please surround spoilers with [spoiler] and [/spoiler]. Thank you.



» blah --
I completely disagree with this review. If you are going to give something a perfect rating, you could at least elaborate more on why it is good. Saying the characters are realistic is one thing, but are they likeable at all? Personally, I found Ed to be whiny and annoying. I really don't care if people mistake him for the younger brother.

Also, I haven't seen the entire series, but I don't see how this series could be influential on anything. At least, it won't be any more influential than any other formulaic shounen series. Even though you say that it is unique because the heroes use alchemy, that doesn't explain much. Are you saying that alchemy is going to be the next big thing in the world of anime?

Anyway, this review was not helpful for me.
» BoneyJellyfish --
"Anyway, this review was not helpful for me."

Why would you be looking for a helpful review if you've already seen it and decided you didn't like it?
» blah --
Well, I guess I just wanted to see exactly why the show is good. Lots of fans have commented on how good it is, but hearing that it is good, and understanding why it is good are two different things.

Also, I never said that I have seen the entire series. I have been trying to decide whether I should give up on the series, or just grin and bear it until the next story arc comes up.
» Ariel Tsuki --
I so agree with the reviewer on Fullmetal Alchemist, it's the best anime I ever seen these recent years, and trust me, I watched a crapload of anime. The characters, story and music well put together for me. I admit that the first thirteen episodes or so the story was slow, but where you can find "filler" episodes so hilarous and still somehow progressed the story? The only gripe I had was the ending, but I forgive them since the movie is gonna have the real one. I enjoyed waiting each week watching this show and don't regret a single second of it.
» .. saga saga .. --
I totally agree with the reviewer. This is one of the best series I have seen. Each of the epsiodes are so well tied to together and even all the filler episodes contribute to the story.

There isnt one topic or character introduced which was expanded on and explained. Everything shown adds to the plot and all characters are fully developed.


» ixellis --
Eh... I have to say that while FMA was a well produced series I don't see how it can get 5/5. Giving FMA a 5/5 sort of lowers the value of 5/5 because well... even if the reviewer is entitled to her own opinion I have to admit if I was someone who hasn't watched FMA I would still not be convinced (I've watched the whole thing.). Because of the way the review was written rather than the show itself.

The point I have is while there's no point about me disagreeing with her opinion (otherwise it'd go on forever and ever), it's just that for 5/5 I would have expected a really long review explaining exactly how it's THAT good (and yes that can be done withotu spoiling), for it to be credible.

I guess reviews should have some comments on impartial things where there isn't so much of preference involved, such as technically how good the story was, and have the 'magic factor' separated (e.g. how much you enjoyed it, whether there was something special about the storytelling, etc.)
» KaeMeera --
LOL! I remember when I saw the first episode for the first time. By the end of it, I was sitting straight up in my chair, eyes wide, jaw to my lap. I think this anime is a gem. It'll probably be one of my favorites for a very very long time. Great review.
» Homunculus Gluttony --
Thanks for all the feedback everyone, both bad and good, as well as for the comments on how awesome this series is, becuase one can never get enough of those. I understand what those who disagree with me are saying and I'll keep some of your advice in mind for my next review.

KaeMeera - I know exactly what you're talking about. I reluctantly watched the first episode thinking it'd be another plotless action anime filled with pointless SD, but was very pleasantly surprised by the end. ^^
» FaTTChun --
Omg, to the user person who said this is not a 5 out of 5, anime, i have to totally disagree with him and agree with everyone else who has replied to this. This anime is amazing. What is there not to like about it? Action, yep it has that, maybe a tad short, but high realistic and high quality action (e.g. people get hurt and the affects are felt). Comedy, has that (although most of them were not funny to me, kind of like the naruto ones). Plots, has a LOT of them, and the twists incorporated into it just amazes me. Caught me out most of the time anyway. Philosophical questions and a recurring dark theme, damn right that is a key part to the anime. What else, Character development and well, pretty much everything you look for in an anime. The ONLY let down i found was a bit of a bathos ending especially with a character that did not fit into the story whatsoever Archer, wtf was up with this stupid deluded character . Apart from that, this is truly a gem of an anime.
» killermonk --
I agree with the reviewer 100%. This series was ingenious in almost every possible way. Highly reccommended.